Categories : Injury Law

Important Notice

For any legal advice, be sure to contact an attorney. Legal issues can be very complicated, which is why the Law Offices of Blaine A Tucker offers FREE consultation and FREE Case Review. In most cases, there is NO FEE, unless you WIN

 

On June 3, the Supreme Court ruled 5-4 to overturn a ruling by Maryland’s Appeals Court regarding law enforcement’s ability to take DNA samples. The ruling means that law enforcement agencies can take DNA from a suspect they have detained in relation to a serious crime. The new ruling means that taking DNA samples will be regarded as part of standard booking procedure, along with taking fingerprints, photographs and other information about the suspect.

Supreme Court Ruling May Mean Big Changes for Criminal Defense Lawyers

Law enforcement agencies were quick to hail the ruling as a victory, according to reports in Reuters. The case involved a rape conviction from 2009. The case was overturned in 2010 when the Maryland appeals court held that the suspect, who was sentenced to life in prison, had his Fifth Amendment rights violated by the DNA gathering. The police had established no connection between the suspect and the rape, which occurred in 2003, when they performed the test. The suspect was arrested on two assault charges at the time that the DNA was gathered, according to the report.

Dissent

Dissent on this ruling came from both conservative and liberal judges. Antonin Scalia, one of the most conservative justices on the court, noted in his dissent that the DNA was not gathered until days after the arrest, though the standard booking procedures were undertaken immediately. There is also some controversy about the use of the term “serious offenses” in the Supreme Court opinion. According to reporting, Scalia noted that DNA could theoretically be gathered after any arrest.

The Maryland Attorney General, Douglas Gansler, called the ruling a “victory” for law enforcement, as quoted in the story. Law enforcement agencies hold that the ruling will allow them to solve cold cases that may have been languishing for years. He also mentioned that the evidence could help to clear the names of those who have been wrongly convicted.

In addition to a mix of conservative and liberal justices, DNA gathering in the fashion addressed by the ruling was opposed by the American Civil Liberties Union. The organization likened the policy to allowing the police to conduct searches without a warrant and without having any particular suspicion that the person arrested committed a particular crime. The Reuters report quotes FBI statistics regarding DNA gathering. According to that information, there are 10 million convicted persons who have had their DNA gathered and 1.3 million people who have been arrested.


Tags:

Checking...

Ouch! There was a server error.
Retry »

Sending message...

FREE Case Review

Fill in the form below for a FREE, No Obligation Case Review

Help Us Prevent Spam

7 - 1 =

Q & A

  • What to do if You have Been in a Car Crash?

    An automobile accident can turn your life upside down in an instant. If you’ve suffered Personal Injury due to car crash, you will suddenly be subject to medical bills, potential […]

  • Filing a Personal Injury or Wrongful Death Claim

    Personal injury attorneys work a wide variety of cases. In some instances, a worker is injured on the job due to lax safety standards or because they were asked to […]

  • Are Defective Products Lawsuits Worthwhile?

    Most of the time, when you hear about someone suing over defective products, it’s a dramatic case with a very large settlement. It’s easy to fault the media for this, […]

  • Premises Injury

    Immediate Action Necessary: Premises Injuries Slip and Fall Accidents Injuries at retail stores and outlets from slip and falls, trip and falls and falling merchandise require immediate action to prevent […]

  • What happens during a personal injury lawsuit?

    Your personal injury firm will determine the facts of your case and will contact the legal representation of the company or person you are filing a claim against. Most personal […]

Auto Accidents

  • Texting While Driving Accidents

    In the United States, distracted driving accounts for hundreds of thousands of automobile accidents every year. In recent years, accidents caused by texting while driving has contributed to an exponential […]

  • Why Do You Need a Houston Auto Accident Law Firm?

    If you or a loved one has suffered any type of personal injury during or resulting from an automobile accident, you may be entitled to monetary compensation from all responsible […]

  • Automobile Accidents Lawsuits

    Even though it’s an everyday occurrence, suing over automobile accidents is sometimes a controversial subject. There are people who sometimes find it unfair that someone is sued over an accident […]

  • Why Drunk Driving Accidents are So Dangerous

    Even when things get out of control, you can count on some common reflexes from most drivers. They’ll generally try to avoid hitting other cars or fixed objects, for one, […]

  • What Causes Truck Accidents?

    How a Truck Injury Lawyer can get you the compensation you deserve Truck accidents are a bit more complex, in many regards, than are passenger car accidents. To start with, […]

  • 18 Wheeler Collisions

    Injuries from accidents involving 18 wheelers require immediate action to prevent destruction of evidence. The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Regulations require certain records be maintained such as driver qualifications, training, […]

Product & Other Liabilities

  • Work Safety and Product Liability

    Most often, when a worker is harmed on the job due to a negligent employer’s actions or lack of action, they have the option to sue. But what if it’s […]

  • Why Product Liability Law Works

    There are plenty of adages about power corrupting. In the practical world, money does equate to power and, of course, corporations have a lot of money to throw around. One […]

  • Class Action vs. Individual Product Liability Claims

    Product liability claims are handled in several different ways, depending upon the circumstances. You have probably heard of class action lawsuits. These are cases where a group of people get […]

  • Baby Toy Recalls

    Some of the most frightening product recalls are those that involve toys. The population most at risk, of course, is young people and this makes it particularly dire when one […]

  • Premise Liability Claims

    Premise liability claims are usually filed when a property owner was negligent and where that negligence led to someone being hurt unnecessarily. The owner of a commercial property has a […]

  • Liability Law and Motorcycle Accidents

    Whenever you get on a motorcycle, you’re willingly taking on more risk than the driver of a passenger car. This is part of the thrill of riding and it’s one […]

  • Compensation for Injuries from Burns and Explosions

    Burns are some of the most devastating of all injuries. They’re among the most painful types of injuries, and this makes the suffering associated with them something most people would […]

  • Product Liability Tips

    Anytime you get injured or harmed from a product that you believe is defective, here are some of the things you need to do: You need to gather and preserve […]

Liability

  • Work Safety and Product Liability

    Most often, when a worker is harmed on the job due to a negligent employer’s actions or lack of action, they have the option to sue. But what if it’s […]

  • Why Product Liability Law Works

    There are plenty of adages about power corrupting. In the practical world, money does equate to power and, of course, corporations have a lot of money to throw around. One […]

  • Class Action vs. Individual Product Liability Claims

    Product liability claims are handled in several different ways, depending upon the circumstances. You have probably heard of class action lawsuits. These are cases where a group of people get […]

  • Baby Toy Recalls

    Some of the most frightening product recalls are those that involve toys. The population most at risk, of course, is young people and this makes it particularly dire when one […]

  • Premise Liability Claims

    Premise liability claims are usually filed when a property owner was negligent and where that negligence led to someone being hurt unnecessarily. The owner of a commercial property has a […]

  • Liability Law and Motorcycle Accidents

    Whenever you get on a motorcycle, you’re willingly taking on more risk than the driver of a passenger car. This is part of the thrill of riding and it’s one […]

  • Compensation for Injuries from Burns and Explosions

    Burns are some of the most devastating of all injuries. They’re among the most painful types of injuries, and this makes the suffering associated with them something most people would […]

  • Product Liability Tips

    Anytime you get injured or harmed from a product that you believe is defective, here are some of the things you need to do: You need to gather and preserve […]